The StrategicPay® Series is a series of hands on, "do it yourself" ("DIY") Toolkits designed to help HR and compensation professionals do work that is
normally hired out to compensation consultants. We call it "compensation consulting at your fingertips..."

Strategic Pay Series Logo

Tag: labor market trends

The Future of Wage Increases in America

The future isn't looking too good for the typical wage earner in America these days. Not surprisingly, wage growth is quite slow right now, but there is also no foreseeable impetus to increase that growth any time soon, unless you're lucky enough to be in a few selected high demand roles (such as for skilled health-care workers and selected technical professionals).

Not only is the labor market in the worst shape in decades, we likely haven't hit bottom yet.  In addition, nearly all economists are predicting a painfully slow jobs recovery over the next few years.  Of the millions of jobs lost in this recession, the concern among many labor market pundits is that a good chunk of these jobs may never come back (i.e., many of the manufacturing job losses), and of the ones that do, the recovery will be several years in the making.

Back to wage growth though, here's the current situation relative to the pre-recession period: in the first half of 2007, wages were growing at a healthy 3.7% annualized rate. In the first half of 2009, wages increased at a 1.3% annualized rate, and that may well go down as the labor market continues to deteriorate (labor market conditions generally lag overall economic trends, so even though we've hit bottom overall, according to most economists, the labor market probably hasn't yet).

The current (August) national unemployment is at 9.7%, and is expected to bottom in the 10%+ range sometime early next year.  That's the good news. IHS Global Insight is predicting that in 2014, the unemployment rate will average 7.6%, which is still well above the unemployment rate before the recession started in late 2007.  The predicted molasses-paced recovery will have a major impact on wage growth in the U.S. for the next few years at the least.

Labor market dynamics are a complex brew of many factors, but at its core is the same "supply and demand" that you learned in Econ 101. With labor current market supply quite high and demand very low (and expected to stay weak for the next few years, due to the slow economic growth being projected), the the case for a strong rebound in wages is not in the cards, barring a much more robust recovery than expected.

It is likely that wage growth could be stuck in the 1.5% to 2.5% range for years, or roughly one-half to two-thirds of historical wage growth.

If this predicted scenario plays out, the implications for the typical American wage earner will be profound. It will also have a large impact on employers, who rely on economic growth to fund their pay-for-performance programs.  For some ideas on how to address these issues, see fellow Compensation Cafe' blogger Margaret O'Hanlon's recent post on dealing with "tiny" merit budgets, and my earlier post on using your  professional creativity in these lean times.


Doug Sayed, SPHR, CCP is founder of Applied HR Strategies Inc., a Seattle area strategic compensation consultancy, and lead author of the StrategicPay Series "Base Pay Toolkit."

A Tech Turnaround?

Is the technology sector about ready to turnaround, or has it at least hit bottom?

The Department of Labor says that technology related-employment actually rose by 7,400 in July, after several months of declines. Granted, 7,400 jobs isn't a lot for the entire country, but that sure beats the 247,000 jobs that were lost overall, and one of the first really positive bottoming-out signs seen yet, at least in the employment arena, which tends to be a lagging economic indicator.

To date, most of the euphoria about the economy bottoming has been about things getting less bad, as opposed to seeing actual positive numbers (like increased retail sales or increased hiring). So, to see the technology sector actually increasing employment is a huge plus.

Of course, one month does not make a trend, but this at least indicates that a bottom is near or here, at least in technology.

If you work in the technology sector, have you seen any positive changes? Leave a comment about what you're seeing in your crystal ball.

The math behind the likely jobless recovery

In today's hyper-paced, cost-conscience world, jobs can disappear in a flash, as we've seen in the past year.

An article on the MS-NBC's site from yesterday, subtitled "In the modern economy, industries vanish and it takes time to replace them" captures todays' world of work well. 

Labor market dynamics have changed dramatically in the past two decades.  In previous generations, mutual employer/employee loyalty helped to fuse together years of long-term employment at a single employer.  That world has gone virtually extinct in today's new short-term thinking, combined with today's economic challenges.  In today's world, productivity, performance, and the immediate economic landscape rule the day.

Today, "Most forecasts predict that Americans are in for a long, painful slog as they try to get back to work. Some forecasts don't have the unemployment rate getting back to "normal" levels of around 5 percent until 2014." We concur with this assessment.

That's not a pretty picture, but one that we have to anticipate as we consider two major forces: a fundamental change in employee/employer dynamics, and a very weak economic landscape.

While the employment rate actually dropped 0.1% in July, don't be fooled; that was just a statistical artifact of people dropping out of the labor force, not the beginning of a labor market resurgence.  The labor market always lags the overall recovery, so don't expect a sustainable improvement until the economy starts recovering and employers feels safe enough to start hiring again.

 

 

Unemployment is Worse Than U.S. Statistics Show

"Part-Time Workers Mask Unemployment Woes"

Reads the headline in the NY Times.  We all know the labor market has done a serious nose-dive in the past year, but its actually worse than the primary government statistics on unemployment indicate. 

That's because the "official" rate that's published doesn't include "discouraged" workers who have dropped out of the labor force (stopped looking for work), and especially the "under-employed," such as persons working part-time instead of full-time, or working in full-time jobs they wouldn't even consider in better times.

June's "official" unemployment rate of 9.5% pales in comparison to the the U.S. Department of Labor's broadest measure (which include the part-time workers described above). For instance, in Michigan, California and Rhode Island, and Oregon, the rate exceeds 20%, or one in five workers in these states (and several other states aren't too far behind this 20% mark).

Most of the hardest hit states are more reliant on manufacturing, housing construction and other infrastructure-related industries.

Since the labor market tends to be a lagging indicator, which often continues to worsen even after the economy officially bottoms, nearly all economists agree that we won't see any significant improvements this year, even if the economy bounces off the bottom in the second half of 2009, as many are predicting today.

Please checkout the article if you're one of those twisted soles (like me!) who enjoys economics. There's a lot of good information in it.

 

 

Storm Before the Calm?

An article in today's Wall Street Journal points out just how weak the labor market picture is, based on the most recent batch of monthly state reports.  Not more than two week's ago (see earlier post) it was predicted that in the third quarter, the employment outlook would be stable, according to the Manpower Employment Outlook Survey (MEOS).  It that's true, than the most recent set of employment reports must be the storm before the calm.

Here's a few examples of how bad things have gotten recently:

  • May 2009 state employment reports showed only two states did not report increased unemployment rates (congrats to Nebraska and Vermont!) for the month.
  • Eight states reported all-time record unemployment rates (since accurate records have been kept - the 30s would certainly have been worse, but that's not much solace today). Here's a quick sampling of a few of the records: 14.1% in Michigan, Oregon at 12.4%, and California at 11.5%.
  • Payrolls were lower in 48 states, compared to the year before.  The largest decline was a 7.4% drop in Arizona, which has been devastated by a crushing real-estate led recession.

Suddenly, the MEOS-predicted 3rd quarter stability is looking pretty shaky, especially since the labor market tends to lag overall economic trends.  Many economists are predicting further labor market weakness in the second half of this year, even if the economy levels out and starts to recover, which many expect will happen sometime in the 3rd or 4th quarter of this year.  Let's hope they are right, at least about the recovery part.

3rd Quarter Employment Outlook is Stable

The 3rd Quarter U.S. Employment Outlook is Stable (not down, and that's a good thing!).  Labor market trends have been quite negative for over a year now, so "stability," if it occurs, would be a vast improvement.

The Manpower Employment Outlook Survey (MEOS), which just published its latest results last week,  shows that the employment outlook over is stable for the 3rd quarter vs. the 2nd quarter of 2009.  Not exactly growth, but as one of my colleagues said recently, "flat is the new growth." For now at least, no further deterioration is the new "up."

"When we account for ongoing calibration of the data, employer attitudes about hiring remain essentially unchanged compared to the previous quarter," said Jeffrey Joerres, chairman and CEO of Manpower Inc. "While the numbers may not be as optimistic as we would like, it is positive to see no further deterioration."

The survey of over 28,000 employers found that 15% anticipate an increase in their staffing levels,  while 13% expect a decrease in their payrolls. Two-thirds (67%) expect no change in their July-September hiring plans and 5% said they were undecided about their hiring intentions.

"The data shows continued hesitancy among employers," said Jonas Prising, president of the Americas for Manpower Inc. "They are treading slowly and watching with guarded optimism, hoping a few quarters of stability will be the precursor to the recovery."

The survey results show employers in seven of the 13 sectors studied expect hiring to remain stable in third quarter compared to second quarter. The survey shows that employers in construction as well as wholesale and retail trade anticipate moderate increases; non-durable goods manufacturing and leisure and hospitality employers expect a slight increase in hiring activity compared to second quarter.

Slight decreases are expected in education and health services and government (these have been among the strongest sectors over the past year). Employers in the following sectors said they will keep hiring levels relatively stable for third quarter: durable goods manufacturing, transportation and utilities, information, financial activities, professional and business services, and other services.

Regionally, the West has a weaker outlook for third quarter compared to second quarter;  all regions have a weaker outlook compared to this time last year.

Let's hope that the anticipated stability in the 3rd quarter leads to improvement in the 4th quarter!